7 Comments
User's avatar
Amanda Craig's avatar

Hard agree about The Bee Sting, and I was glad it won the Nero. Also delighted about Orbital.

Expand full comment
Jason Cobley's avatar

That was a great read. I was initially disappointed with Orbital, but fortunately it’s short enough to reread and reevaluate. It’s deceptively straightforward but actually beautifully written.

Expand full comment
Susanna Crossman's avatar

This was excellent. Had me giggling!

Expand full comment
Jude Cook's avatar

Thanks! Orbital really is a wonder by the way if you haven't read yet. Looking forward to The Orange Notebooks storming the Booker.

Expand full comment
Emily Midorikawa's avatar

I'm so glad you decided to write up this episode, with its entertaining insights into the often opaque culture surrounding literary prizes.

Expand full comment
Jude Cook's avatar

Thanks Emily! It's really arbitrary who they invite to the Booker parties. It's kind of down to if they remembered you reviewed some of their books once.

Expand full comment
Steve Mitchelmore's avatar

I don't believe deciding between novels when a prize is involved should be "a matter of taste [and] maddeningly subjective". The shortlists on the major prizes in the UK are limited to a very narrow understanding of 'literary', what one might call 'Waterstones 3-for-2 table lyrical realism', so it ends up being a toss-up between more or less identical novels.

When it comes to the Booker and others (even those claiming to be rewarding innovative fiction), I think of Beckett's Molloy keeping warm by wrapping himself in swathes of newspapers: "The Times Literary Supplement was admirably adapted to this purpose, of a never-failing toughness and impermeability. Even farts made no impression on it."

Expand full comment